Fair Lawn's Favorite Scoop Since Day One

Ready to Explore
What Actually
Tastes Like Summer?

Hand-churned small batches, locally sourced ingredients, and flavors you won't find anywhere else — right here on River Road.

See Our Flavors (201) 794-8112

Scroll

Ice cream being scooped at New Territories Ice Cream in Fair Lawn

Our Story

A Neighborhood
Tradition, One Scoop
at a Time

New Territories Ice Cream was born from a simple belief: that the best ice cream starts with the best ingredients and a whole lot of patience. Located on River Road in Fair Lawn, we've been serving our community handcrafted frozen desserts made in small batches, every single day.

Our founders came here with empty freezers and full imaginations — determined to create something that makes people stop, taste, and come back for more. Every flavor on our board is a story worth telling, from the classic vanilla that tastes like childhood to the seasonal specials that keep our regulars guessing.

30+

Signature Flavors

100%

Hand-Churned

Local

Ingredients

Our Flavors

Curated for the
Curious Palate

Every batch is churned fresh daily. Some flavors are here to stay — others show up for a season and vanish without a trace.

Classic

Madagascar Vanilla

Real vanilla beans, slow-churned to creamy perfection. The one that started it all — and still the one everyone orders first.

Indulgent

Dark Chocolate Ganache

Belgian chocolate, 72% cacao, folded into a velvety base. For the people who take their dessert seriously.

Seasonal

Strawberry Fields

Jersey berries, picked at peak ripeness. Bright, tangy, and impossibly fresh — available only when the season says yes.

Bold

Ceremonial Matcha

Imported Japanese matcha, whisked into a smooth, earthy base. Not sweet — sophisticated. A flavor that demands attention.

Fan Favorite

Brown Butter Salted Caramel

Brown butter caramel ribboned through a sandy base with a whisper of Maldon sea salt. The one that converts skeptics.

Vegan

Mango Coconut

Coconut cream base, Alphonso mango purée, no dairy required. Bright, lush, and proof that plant-based can be anything but plain.

The Experience

More Than a Scoop
— It's an Occasion

From the moment you walk in, everything is designed to make this feel special. Here's what makes us different.

Small Batch, Big Heart

Every flavor is made in limited quantities and churned fresh each morning. If it's gone by noon, it's gone — that's how we keep every scoop at its peak.

Locally Sourced

We partner with nearby farms and producers for our dairy, fruit, and specialty ingredients. Supporting local isn't a slogan here — it's our supply chain.

Made for Sharing

Three-scoop cones, half-pints for the indecisive, or a full quart to bring home. however you enjoy it, we'll make sure it feels like a treat worth savoring.

Kind Words

What Our Neighbors
Are Saying

We don't need fancy reviews — just real people coming back for seconds, thirds, and fourths.

We drive past a dozen other places just to stop here. The brown butter caramel is unreal — my kids argue over who gets the last bite every single time.

Sarah M.

Fair Lawn Resident

I brought my out-of-town friends here and they couldn't believe this was in New Jersey. The matcha flavor alone is worth the trip. Absolute perfection.

David L.

Local Regular

As someone with dairy sensitivities, finding a place that takes vegan ice cream this seriously felt like a gift. The mango coconut changed my entire perspective.

Priya K.

Palisades Park

Ready to Explore
What Actually
Tastes Like Summer?

A Neighborhood
Tradition, One Scoop
at a Time